Low Productivity of Indian Dairy Animals:  Challenge and Mitigation Strategies 

Low Productivity of Indian Dairy Animals:  Challenge and Mitigation Strategies

Simran jeet Singh¹, Ekta Bisht²

¹PG Scholar, Department of Veterinary Medicine, College of Veterinary and Animal Sciences, GB Pant University of Agriculture and Technology, Pantnagar, Udhamsingh Nagar, Uttarakhand- 263145

²PG Scholar, Department of Veterinary Pathology, Dr. GC Negi College of Veterinary and Animal Sciences, CSKHPKV, Palampur, Himachal Pradesh-176062.

Abstract:

India stands as the world’s leading milk producer, yet faces a significant challenge with low productivity of its dairy animals. There are multifaceted issues underlying this problem. Genetic limitations are a primary factor, with indigenous breeds having lower milk yields compared to exotic breeds. Nutritional deficiencies, stemming from poor quality feed and traditional feeding practices, further exacerbate the issue. Inadequate healthcare and frequent disease outbreaks significantly impact animal health and productivity. Additionally, suboptimal management practices, including poor housing conditions and inefficient milking techniques, hinder productivity. Socioeconomic factors, such as the predominance of smallholder farmers with limited access to resources and markets, also play a critical role. To mitigate these challenges, a comprehensive set of strategies are needed to be implemented. Genetic improvement programs tailored to enhance the productivity of indigenous breeds, combined with targeted crossbreeding initiatives, are essential. Nutritional interventions, such as promoting the cultivation of high-quality fodder and providing balanced rations, can significantly improve animal health and milk yields. Strengthening veterinary infrastructure and implementing robust preventive healthcare measures are crucial for disease management. Improved management practices, including better housing, hygiene, and farmer training, are necessary for sustainable productivity gains. Economic and policy support, such as financial assistance and development of organized marketing channels, can empower farmers and ensure fair prices for their produce. By adopting these strategies and leveraging successful models like the Amul cooperative movement and the National Dairy Plan, India can significantly enhance its dairy productivity, ensuring better livelihoods for farmers and meeting the growing demand for milk and dairy products. This multifaceted approach offers a pathway to unlocking the full potential of India’s dairy sector.

Key Words:   Dairy productivity, Genetic limitations, Nutritional deficiencies, Veterinary

                      infrastructure, Socioeconomic factors

Introduction

 India, renowned as the world’s largest milk producer, contributes significantly to the global dairy supply, yet it grapples with the challenge of low productivity per dairy animal. The average milk yield per cow in India is approximately 4-5 liters per day, which starkly contrasts with the 20-30 liters per day achieved by dairy animals in countries like the United States and Israel. This discrepancy underscores the need to address the underlying factors inhibiting productivity.

The Indian dairy sector is a cornerstone of the agrarian economy, providing livelihoods for millions of rural households and contributing substantially to the nation’s nutritional security. The sector’s growth has been fueled by the cooperative movement, government initiatives, and increasing demand for dairy products. However, despite these advancements, the productivity of Indian dairy animals remains suboptimal.

Several interrelated challenges contribute to this low productivity. Genetic limitations of indigenous breeds, inadequate nutrition, poor healthcare and disease management, substandard management practices, and socioeconomic constraints all play pivotal roles. Indigenous breeds, while well-adapted to local conditions, generally have lower milk production potential compared to exotic breeds. Nutritional deficiencies, due to inadequate and imbalanced diets, significantly impact milk yields. Additionally, limited access to quality veterinary services and frequent disease outbreaks further exacerbates the issue. Poor housing and sanitation, coupled with inefficient milking practices, also detract from potential productivity. Socioeconomic factors, such as the dominance of smallholder farmers with restricted access to technology and credit, further impede progress.

To address these multifaceted challenges, a comprehensive approach is required.

Challenges Facing Indian Dairy Farming

India’s dairy farming sector is riddled with numerous challenges that hinder its potential to achieve high productivity levels. These challenges are multifaceted, encompassing genetic, nutritional, healthcare, management, and socioeconomic aspects. Here, we delve into the primary obstacles that contribute to the low productivity of Indian dairy animals.

• Genetic Limitations

Genetic limitations are a fundamental challenge facing Indian dairy farming. These limitations primarily stem from the reliance on indigenous breeds and the complexities of crossbreeding programs. Understanding these issues is crucial for formulating effective strategies to enhance dairy productivity.

• Indigenous Breeds

India’s dairy sector relies heavily on indigenous cattle breeds such as Gir, Sahiwal, Red Sindhi, and Tharparkar. While these breeds are well-suited to local environmental conditions and exhibit strong resistance to diseases and heat stress, they generally have lower genetic potential for milk production compared to exotic breeds. The average milk yield of indigenous breeds ranges between 4-5 liters per day, which is significantly lower than the 20-30 liters per day produced by high-yielding exotic breeds like Holstein Friesian and Jersey.

Indigenous breeds possess valuable traits such as disease resistance, adaptability to harsh climates, and the ability to thrive on low-quality feed. However, their lower milk production capacity presents a significant hurdle in meeting the rising demand for milk and dairy products in India.

• Crossbreeding Programs

To overcome the low productivity of indigenous breeds, India has implemented various crossbreeding programs. These programs aim to combine the high milk yield potential of exotic breeds with the adaptability and disease resistance of indigenous breeds. While crossbreeding has led to the development of crossbred cattle that exhibit higher milk yields, it has also introduced several challenges:

• Adaptability: Crossbred animals often face difficulties adapting to local climatic conditions. They are more susceptible to heat stress and other environmental stresses that indigenous breeds can withstand.
• Disease Susceptibility:Crossbreeds tend to have higher susceptibility to diseases compared to indigenous breeds. This necessitates better healthcare and management practices, which may not always be available in rural areas.
• Management Requirements:Crossbred animals require more intensive management and care. They need better quality feed, regular veterinary care, and proper housing facilities to maintain their health and productivity. Smallholder farmers, who dominate the Indian dairy sector, often lack the resources and knowledge to provide such care.
• Genetic Diversity:Crossbreeding programs, if not managed carefully, can lead to the erosion of valuable genetic traits in indigenous breeds. This loss of genetic diversity can have long-term negative impacts on the resilience and sustainability of the dairy sector.

Strategies for Genetic Improvement

Addressing the genetic limitations of Indian dairy animals requires a balanced approach that leverages the strengths of both indigenous and exotic breeds. Key strategies include:

• Selective Breeding:Implementing robust selective breeding programs focused on improving the genetic potential of indigenous breeds. This involves selecting the best-performing animals for breeding to enhance milk yield while preserving their adaptability and disease resistance traits.
• Crossbreeding Policies:Developing region-specific crossbreeding policies that ensure optimal genetic combinations. These policies should aim to balance high milk yield with traits like disease resistance and environmental adaptability.
• Conservation of Indigenous Breeds:Promoting the conservation and sustainable use of indigenous breeds through initiatives such as establishing breed conservation centers and providing incentives for farmers to maintain purebred indigenous cattle.
• Genetic Research:Investing in genetic research and biotechnology to identify and propagate desirable traits in both indigenous and crossbred cattle. Techniques such as genomic selection and marker-assisted breeding can accelerate genetic improvement efforts.

By addressing the genetic limitations through these strategies, India can enhance the productivity of its dairy animals, ensuring a more sustainable and profitable dairy sector.

• Nutritional Deficiencies

Nutritional deficiencies represent a critical challenge in the Indian dairy farming sector, significantly impacting the productivity and health of dairy animals. Adequate nutrition is essential for optimal milk production, reproductive efficiency, and overall animal well-being. However, various factors contribute to the widespread issue of nutritional deficiencies in India’s dairy industry.

• Feed Quality and Availability
• Inadequate Nutrition:Dairy animals in India often receive diets that are deficient in essential nutrients. The typical diet, which includes crop residues, dry fodder, and locally available greens, often lacks sufficient proteins, vitamins, and minerals needed for high milk production.
• Seasonal Variations:The availability and quality of fodder fluctuate with seasons. During the dry season, there is a scarcity of green fodder, forcing farmers to rely on poor-quality dry fodder that does not meet the nutritional needs of dairy animals. This seasonal shortage leads to periods of nutritional deficiency, adversely affecting milk yield and animal health.
• Imbalanced Diets:Traditional feeding practices frequently result in imbalanced diets. Farmers may not have the knowledge or resources to formulate balanced rations that provide the correct proportions of energy, protein, vitamins, and minerals. This imbalance can lead to issues such as low milk production, poor reproductive performance, and increased susceptibility to diseases.
• Feeding Practices
• Lack of Awareness:Many smallholder farmers lack awareness about the nutritional requirements of high-yielding dairy animals. There is a limited understanding of how to balance diets effectively to optimize milk production and maintain animal health.
• Economic Constraints:Financial limitations often prevent farmers from purchasing high-quality feed and supplements. High costs of commercial feed and mineral supplements discourage their use, leading to continued reliance on nutritionally inadequate local feed resources.
• Fodder Preservation:Poor fodder preservation techniques contribute to nutritional deficiencies. Improper storage methods result in significant wastage and degradation of fodder quality, especially during the monsoon season. This further reduces the availability of nutritious feed during the lean periods.
• Nutritional Interventions

Addressing nutritional deficiencies requires a multifaceted approach involving education, resource availability, and innovative practices. Key strategies include:

Fodder Development

• High-Yielding Fodder Crops: Promoting the cultivation of high-yielding and nutrient-rich fodder crops such as alfalfa, hybrid Napier grass, and legumes can improve the quality and availability of feed.
• Fodder Banks: Establishing community fodder banks can help ensure a consistent supply of quality fodder throughout the year, mitigating the impact of seasonal shortages.

Balanced Rations:

• Formulated Feeds:Providing access to scientifically formulated feed that meets the nutritional needs of dairy animals. These feeds should be balanced for energy, protein, vitamins, and minerals.
• Ration Balancing Programs:Implementing ration balancing programs at the village level to educate farmers on preparing balanced diets using locally available resources. These programs can help optimize the use of available feed and improve animal nutrition.
• Supplementation
• Mineral and Vitamin Supplements:Encouraging the use of mineral and vitamin supplements to address specific deficiencies that cannot be met through regular fodder alone. Providing these supplements at subsidized rates can enhance their adoption.
• Fortified Feed:Developing and promoting fortified feed products that incorporate essential micronutrients can help address common deficiencies.

Training and Extension Services:

Farmer Education: Conducting regular training programs and workshops to educate farmers about the nutritional requirements of dairy animals and effective feeding practices.

Extension Services: Strengthening extension services to provide farmers with ongoing support and advice on feed management, fodder cultivation, and nutrition.

Fodder Preservation Techniques:

• Silage and Hay Making:Promoting the use of silage and hay-making techniques to preserve green fodder during periods of abundance for use during lean seasons.
• Improved Storage:Implementing better storage facilities and methods to reduce post-harvest losses and maintain fodder quality.

By addressing nutritional deficiencies through these interventions, the productivity and health of Indian dairy animals can be significantly improved. Enhanced nutrition will lead to higher milk yields, better reproductive performance, and overall improved livelihoods for dairy farmers.

• Socioeconomic Factors

Smallholder Dominance: The Indian dairy sector is characterized by smallholder farmers who have limited resources, access to technology, and financial means. This makes it challenging to implement modern dairy farming practices and invest in productivity-enhancing technologies.

Market Access: Many dairy farmers face difficulties in accessing organized markets. Fluctuating milk prices, lack of reliable market channels, and inadequate infrastructure for milk collection and distribution limit their profitability and discourage investment in improving productivity.

• Healthcare and Disease Management

Effective healthcare and disease management are crucial components in enhancing the productivity of dairy animals in India. Poor health and frequent disease outbreaks significantly reduce milk yield, increase mortality rates, and lead to substantial economic losses for farmers. Addressing these challenges involves improving veterinary services, implementing preventive healthcare measures, and managing diseases through effective strategies.

• Veterinary Services
• Limited Access:In many rural areas of India, access to quality veterinary services is severely limited. The shortage of veterinarians, inadequate veterinary infrastructure, and lack of mobile veterinary units restrict timely diagnosis and treatment of diseases.
• Quality of Care:Even where veterinary services are available, the quality of care is often compromised due to insufficient training of veterinary staff, lack of modern diagnostic tools, and limited availability of medicines and vaccines.
• Preventive Healthcare:Preventive healthcare measures, such as regular vaccinations, deworming, and health check-ups, are not widely practiced. This leads to higher incidences of preventable diseases and reproductive disorders that adversely affect productivity.
• Disease Outbreaks
• Infectious Diseases:Dairy animals in India are susceptible to various infectious diseases such as mastitis, foot-and-mouth disease (FMD), brucellosis, and bovine tuberculosis. These diseases can cause significant economic losses due to reduced milk production, increased veterinary costs, and loss of animals.
• Parasitic Infections:Parasitic infections, both internal and external, are common and lead to poor health and productivity. Inadequate control measures and poor sanitation practices contribute to the prevalence of these infections.
• Zoonotic Diseases:Diseases that can be transmitted between animals and humans, such as brucellosis and bovine tuberculosis, pose additional risks to both animal and public health.

Strategies for Improved Healthcare and Disease Management

• Strengthening Veterinary Infrastructure:
• Mobile Veterinary Units:Deploying mobile veterinary units to reach remote and underserved areas can provide timely diagnosis and treatment, improving overall animal health.
• Veterinary Clinics:Establishing more veterinary clinics equipped with modern diagnostic tools and well-trained staff can enhance the quality of care.

Preventive Healthcare Programs:

• Vaccination Campaigns:Implementing widespread vaccination campaigns to control major infectious diseases such as FMD, brucellosis, and bovine tuberculosis. Ensuring availability and affordability of vaccines is crucial.
• Regular Deworming:Promoting regular deworming schedules to control parasitic infections, improve animal health, and enhance productivity.
• Health Check-ups:Conducting regular health check-ups to monitor the health status of dairy animals and implement timely interventions.
• Farmer Training and Awareness:
• Educational Programs:Organizing training programs to educate farmers on the importance of preventive healthcare, early disease detection, and proper treatment protocols.
• Hygiene Practices:Teaching farmers about good hygiene practices, including proper milking techniques, sanitation of animal housing, and safe handling of sick animals.
• Disease Surveillance and Reporting:
• Surveillance Systems:Establishing robust disease surveillance systems to monitor disease outbreaks and trends, allowing for rapid response and containment.
• Reporting Mechanisms:Encouraging farmers to report disease incidents promptly and providing channels for easy reporting and feedback.
• Research and Development:
• Disease Research:Investing in research to understand the epidemiology of prevalent diseases and develop effective vaccines and treatments.
• Innovative Solutions:Exploring innovative healthcare solutions, such as telemedicine, to provide remote veterinary consultation and support.
• Public-Private Partnerships:
• Collaborative Efforts: Promoting collaboration between government agencies, private veterinary practitioners, non-governmental organizations, and research institutions to enhance veterinary services and disease management efforts.
• Funding and Resources:Securing funding and resources from both public and private sectors to support healthcare initiatives and infrastructure development.
• Case Studies and Best Practices
• Successful initiatives in improving dairy animal productivity
• Operation Flood in India
• Amul Cooperative Model
• Operation Flood in Bangladesh
• Lessons learned from international experiences
• Feed Management Practices in New Zealand:
• Technology Adoption in the Netherlands
• Selective Breeding Programs in Brazil

• Policy implications

Play a crucial role in shaping the landscape of dairy animal productivity enhancement. Here are some key policy recommendations derived from the challenges and mitigation strategies discussed:

• Genetic Improvement Policies:

Establish a national breeding program focused on indigenous breeds with high milk-producing potential. Provide incentives for selective breeding practices and encourage the adoption of advanced reproductive technologies. Strengthen regulatory frameworks to ensure the quality and traceability of breeding stock.

• Nutrition Management Policies:

Develop guidelines for formulating balanced diets and promote the use of locally available feed resources. Subsidize the production and distribution of quality feed and supplements, especially for small-scale dairy farmers. Invest in research and development to improve feed efficiency and explore alternative feed sources.

• Enhanced Management Practices:

Implement training and extension programs to educate farmers on best practices in animal health management, housing, and sanitation. Provide financial support for the construction of modern dairy facilities and infrastructure upgrades. Strengthen veterinary services in rural areas through the establishment of veterinary clinics and mobile veterinary units.

• Socio-economic Interventions:

Expand access to credit facilities, insurance schemes, and government subsidies for dairy farmers, particularly smallholders. Launch public awareness campaigns to promote the importance of dairy farming and encourage youth participation in the sector. Facilitate market linkages and establish transparent pricing mechanisms to ensure fair returns for dairy farmers.

• Policy Coordination and Integration:

Foster collaboration among government agencies, research institutions, dairy cooperatives, and private sector stakeholders to streamline policy implementation and resource allocation. Integrate dairy animal productivity enhancement initiatives into broader agricultural development programs and strategies. Monitor and evaluate the impact of policies regularly to identify areas for improvement and fine-tune interventions accordingly.

• Incentivizing Innovation and Technology Adoption:

Offer tax incentives, grants, and research funding to incentivize innovation in dairy farming technologies and practices. Promote the adoption of digital solutions, such as precision farming tools and farm management software, to enhance efficiency and productivity.

Facilitate knowledge transfer and capacity-building initiatives to ensure widespread adoption of technological innovations across the dairy value chain. By implementing these policy recommendations in a coordinated and inclusive manner, policymakers can create an enabling environment for enhancing dairy animal productivity, thereby contributing to the sustainable growth of the dairy sector, rural livelihood improvement, and food security in India.

• Future Directions and Research Opportunities

The pursuit of enhancing dairy animal productivity is an ongoing journey that presents numerous opportunities for research, innovation, and technological advancement. Here are some future directions and research opportunities in this domain:

• Genomic Selection and Precision Breeding:

Explore the use of genomic selection techniques to accelerate genetic gain for traits related to milk production, fertility, and disease resistance. Investigate the potential of gene editing technologies, such as CRISPR-Cas9, for targeted genetic improvements in dairy cattle. Develop robust bioinformatics tools and databases for genomic analysis and selection in diverse dairy cattle populations.

• Nutrigenomics and Precision Nutrition:

Conduct research on the interactions between genetics, diet, and metabolic pathways to optimize nutritional interventions for dairy animals. Investigate the role of specific nutrients, bioactive compounds, and feed additives in enhancing milk yield, quality, and animal health. Explore personalized feeding strategies based on individual animal requirements and metabolic profiles.

• Smart Farming Technologies:

Harness the potential of Internet of Things (IoT) devices, sensors, and data analytics for real-time monitoring of dairy animal health, behavior, and performance. Develop decision support systems and predictive models to optimize feed management, breeding decisions, and herd health management. Integrate artificial intelligence and machine learning algorithms to automate farm operations and improve productivity while reducing resource inputs.

• Climate-Resilient Dairy Farming:

Study the impact of climate change on dairy animal productivity and explore adaptive breeding strategies for resilience to heat stress, drought, and disease outbreaks.

Develop climate-smart feeding practices and forage management techniques to mitigate environmental impacts and optimize resource utilization.

Evaluate the potential of alternative energy sources, such as solar power and biogas, for sustainable dairy farm operations.

• Value-Added Dairy Products and Market Diversification:

Investigate novel processing technologies and formulations for the production of value-added dairy products with enhanced nutritional profiles and extended shelf life. Explore opportunities for diversifying dairy product portfolios to meet evolving consumer preferences and emerging market trends. Conduct market research and consumer studies to identify niche markets and value chain opportunities for dairy farmers.

• Cross-Sectoral Collaboration and Knowledge Exchange:

Foster interdisciplinary collaboration between agriculture, veterinary science, biotechnology, and engineering disciplines to address complex challenges in dairy animal productivity enhancement. Facilitate knowledge exchange and technology transfer through research networks, industry partnerships, and international collaborations. Engage stakeholders across the dairy value chain, including farmers, processors, policymakers, and consumers, in participatory research and innovation initiatives.

By embracing these future directions and research opportunities, the dairy industry can unlock new avenues for sustainable growth, resilience, and innovation, ensuring the long-term viability and competitiveness of dairy animal productivity enhancement efforts.

• Conclusion

The productivity of Indian dairy animals is a critical factor in ensuring food security, rural livelihoods, and economic prosperity. Despite being the world’s largest milk producer, India faces persistent challenges in maximizing the potential of its dairy sector. From genetics and nutrition to management practices and socio-economic factors, a multifaceted approach is required to address the underlying issues and unlock the full productivity potential of dairy animals. The challenges hindering dairy animal productivity in India and proposed comprehensive mitigation strategies to overcome these obstacles. Through genetic improvement, nutrition management, enhanced management practices, and socio-economic interventions, stakeholders can work collaboratively to create an enabling environment for dairy farmers to thrive.

Moreover, case studies and best practices from India and other countries have illustrated the effectiveness of targeted interventions in enhancing dairy animal productivity. Initiatives such as Operation Flood, the Amul cooperative model, and selective breeding programs have demonstrated the transformative impact of strategic investments and policy support in the dairy sector. Policy implications, including genetic improvement policies, nutrition management policies, enhanced management practices, socio-economic interventions, and incentivizing innovation, are crucial for shaping the future trajectory of dairy animal productivity enhancement. By integrating these recommendations into national dairy development programs and fostering collaboration among stakeholders, policymakers can accelerate progress towards a more resilient, sustainable, and competitive dairy industry. Looking ahead, future research opportunities in genomics, precision nutrition, smart farming technologies, climate-resilient dairy farming, value-added dairy products, and cross-sectoral collaboration hold immense potential for driving innovation and transformation in the dairy sector.

In conclusion, by addressing the challenges, implementing targeted strategies, and embracing innovation, India can realize its vision of a thriving dairy industry that not only meets the growing demand for nutritious dairy products but also uplifts the lives of millions of dairy farmers and contributes to the nation’s economic growth and food security

References

Singh, M., Kumar, A., Rastogi, A., Pandey, A., & Kumar, A. (2019). Challenges and Opportunities in Indian Dairy Sector for Sustainable Development. Indian Journal of

Animal Research, 53(3), 299-309.

 

Singh, R., & Singh, S. (2018). Dairy development in India: policies, performance and potential.

Indian Journal of Agricultural Sciences, 88(6), 911-923.

 

Chauhan, H., Kumar, P., & Sharma, R. (2017). Dairy Development and Challenges in India: A

Review. International Journal of Pure and Applied Bioscience, 5(5), 579-586.

 

Kumar, N., & Sanghi, N. (2019). Challenges in Indian Dairy Industry: Policy Initiatives and

Impact Analysis. Indian Journal of Dairy Science, 72(2), 191-198.

 

Sharma, A., Sood, N., & Singh, S. P. (2018). Performance, prospects and challenges of Indian

dairy sector. International Journal of Livestock Research, 8(4), 246-256.

 

Kumar, P., & Kumar, S. (2018). A review on challenges of dairy development in India.

International Journal of Current Microbiology and Applied Sciences, 7(5), 2049-2055.

 

Rana, K. S., Singh, S. B., & Maurya, V. P. (2020). Growth, constraints and prospects of dairy

industry in India. Indian Journal of Animal Sciences, 90(5), 672-684.

 

Singh, R., & Kumar, S. (2017). Challenges and Opportunities of Dairy Farming in India: A

Review. International Journal of Agriculture, Environment and Biotechnology, 10(1), 1-9.